What No One Tells You About Consistently Profitable Trading

January 17, 2022
Read time:
3 minutes

If you had no money and I gave you one dollar, would you consider yourself financially wealthy?

Most people would say no.

What if I gave you $40 million instead? Would you consider yourself financially wealthy then?

The answer is probably “yes”.

Therefore, this means if I kept giving you one dollar over and over again, there would come a point in time where one extra dollar would be the difference between being wealthy or not. 

The question is, what is that point?

This is known as the bald man paradox and it relates to a strange problem with newly profitable traders.

Newly Profitable Traders End up Disappointed

When traders start becoming consistently profitable for the first time, something strange often happens.

They become frustrated and disappointed! 

The problem relates to the term ‘consistently profitable’. It’s usually treated as a destination to be reached rather than just another milestone in the learning process.

Part of the issue comes from the fact that the phrase ‘becoming a consistently profitable trader’ is thrown around tirelessly as if it’s the ultimate goal for traders. 

It makes it seem like the progression for a trader is this:

  1. You start off burning out accounts (losing 100% of the capital). 
  2. You then start losing a bit less than that each month. 
  3. Progressively over time, you lose a bit less and a bit less. 
  4. Then you finally pop through the break-even point into untold riches as a consistently profitable trader.

Here’s what that looks like:

As you can see, there’s a problem. There’s a big gap between reaching break-even and making huge returns. That’s because, this isn’t actually how life works.

Being consistently profitable simply means that your returns are above break even (you are not losing money from your trading) and you’re doing it with a consistent and repeatable approach.

Here’s what actually happens,

  1. You start off burning out accounts (losing 100% of the capital). 
  2. You then start losing a bit less than that each month. 
  3. Progressively over time, you lose a bit less and a bit less (each improvement is harder won than the last)
  4. You reach the break-even point. Again, the gains are slower and more incremental.
  5. You edge your way into being profitable.

Like any skill, the better you get, the slower your progress is, as improvements are hard-won. 

Moving to the next step in your development takes a lot of time, work and effort. However, if you stay committed and work in the right way, you finally push through to being consistently profitable. 

Why Newly Profitable Traders Get Frustrated

So traders have spent all that time learning. All that time losing. And finally they are making profits every month… but it’s only 1 or 2%!

“Was all that effort for this? Consistently profitable trading was meant to make me wealthy!”

The reality is, they’ve just made yet another marginal gain in their performance and there will be many more to come as long as they keep putting in the same effort. Increasing your average monthly returns from 1% to 1.2% doesn’t seem like much, but that will soon become 2%, which leads to 3%, then 4% and so on. 

But instead of seeing the situation for what it is, they feel disheartened as the reality doesn’t match their expectations for this huge achievement.

The fact is, trading isn’t black and white. There’s more to it than just being either a losing trader or a profitable trader. It’s a complex skill and just like learning and developing any other performance skill, there isn’t an end destination.

Rather than working towards ‘completing’ your trading development as if it’s a computer game, just focus on continually getting a bit better every day, week or month. Over time you’ll reach the returns you desire without even realising you’ve arrived.


Our latest articles

Trading Development
Being a full-time trader has its own unique challenges. Here are the three biggest things you should NEVER do.
Trading Development
Why is trading harder to master than other skills? Discover the psychological traps and learn practical strategies to navigate the trader's journey
Trading Development
Achieve Trading Success with a 3-Phase Approach: Go from skill development to consistent profitability, while avoiding common pitfalls